Student killed in Dubai crash: Why illegal transport could prove deadly for children

Educators are encouraging parents to prioritise their children's safety over saving money and to avoid using illegal transportation services.

This warning follows a recent incident in which a, and 11 others were injured in a vehicle rollover on the Hatta-Lahbab road on Tuesday. The car was apparently a rented vehicle that had picked up the pupils from school, after dismissal.

After the incident, spoke with educators to explore how schools can monitor the alleged use of unauthorised transportation by parents, often driven by concerns over costs and extended travel times.

Dr Arogya Reddy Principal, Ambassador School Sharjah, said: “School buses are highly recommended due to the well-trained staff on board. Moreover, bus attendants assist with boarding and de-boarding, ensuring smooth operations while adhering to schedules. All bus personnel are approved by regulatory bodies such as Sharjah Private Education Authority (SPEA) and Roads and Transport Authority (RTA), and safety protocols are strictly followed. The buses are equipped with 360-degree cameras, ensuring comprehensive monitoring. Compliance with regulations is thoroughly addressed.”

Schools heads reiterated that a school bus offers a highly safe and secure mode of transportation for children. It is well-organised, with strict monitoring systems and necessary permits in place.

The personnel involved are trained, authorised, and held accountable for their actions, demonstrating a strong sense of responsibility.

“Private drivers often lack proper training or orientation. Some drivers tend to overcrowd their vehicles with children and rush due to multiple pickups. I've also observed some drivers taking off-road routes, which poses potential risks,” he added.

When schools were asked about reducing transportation expenses to make the school bus service more accessible to parents, educators stressed that the cost of school transportation remains slightly higher due to inherent expenses.

Reddy said: “Conversely, when parents express concerns about the cost of school buses, they often fail to realise that their savings (with unauthorised transport) are minimal. In fact, if they crunch the numbers, the monthly savings could be as little as Dh40 depending on the school. It's also important for parents to recognise that school transportation fees are approved by regulatory authorities, who thoroughly assess the market before endorsing them for schools.”

“The only time parents might save money is during school breaks. For instance, if a school operates for only two weeks in December, parents may still have to pay for the entire month to cover staff costs. But if you look at the bigger picture parents must prioritise their children's safety over money,” added Reddy.

School leaders noted that making school transportation more affordable is a significant step toward ensuring that all students have access to safe and reliable transport.

Lisa Johnson, Principal, American Academy for Girls earlier said: “We are continually looking into ways to keep our school transport safe and affordable, thus making school buses a preferred option for more families, and reducing the chance that parents will consider the use of unregulated services.”

John Carvalho used to spend Dh800 per month on his son’s school commute. The expat’s 11-year-old had to sit for over an hour and a half on the school bus for a mere 8km journey.

Frustrated by the “exorbitant” cost and lengthy travel time, Carvalho has now switched to a private transportation service. “I prefer carpooling since we live in Satwa and my son’s school is in Al Quoz,” he said. “Not only does my son save about an hour-and-a half on each trip, but it’s also more cost-effective,” he told Khaleej Times.

While some parents complain of long commutes and high costs, others prioritise safety.

Father of an eight-year-old, Arijit Nandi said: “On the way to school, we carpool with a friend. However, on the way back, since both my wife and I are at work, we prefer that our child returns on the school bus, which costs us about Dh3,000 per term, totalling a little over Dh9,000 annually.”

Nandi’s friend, on the other hand, has hired a driver with his own car to pick up her children from school. “But as we weren’t comfortable with a third-party driver who might only have a licence but no proper training in handling children, we opted for the school bus only for pickup,” Nandi said.